Kathie Sherrill, a 74-year-old retiree from Troy, Michigan, has been enjoying retirement for nearly 10 years. But recently, something changed. For the first time in years, she found herself online, checking her Social Security payment to make sure it had been deposited into her bank account as expected. The reason for her worry? Rising uncertainty about Social Security’s future.
Sherrill is not alone. Many retirees are feeling anxious about their Social Security payments. This fear, dubbed “Social Security insecurity,” has many retirees on edge. Sherrill explained, “I have never really worried about it as much as I have this year.” She was relieved to find her payment in her account in March, but the concern still lingers.
Rising Concerns About Social Security
Since early February, the AARP, a nonprofit organization that advocates for seniors, has seen a sharp increase in calls to its customer service line. The number of inquiries related to Social Security concerns has nearly doubled, reaching more than 2,000 calls per week. A spokesperson from AARP shared that this increase in calls has shown no sign of slowing down.
John Hishta, the senior vice president of campaigns at AARP, reassured the public, stating, “Social Security has never missed a payment, and AARP and our tens of millions of members are not going to stand by and let that happen now.” While his words may sound comforting, many seniors are still worried that their benefits could be interrupted.
The Spread of Bad Advice on Social Media
In the midst of these concerns, there’s also been a rise in misleading advice on social media. One post urged people to move their money from their main account, where they receive Social Security payments, to another account. The suggestion was based on the idea that a system could “declare you dead” and force your bank to return the funds. This kind of advice can cause unnecessary panic and may even put people at risk. Moving Social Security payments to different accounts could make it easier for debt collectors to seize the money.
Social Security has been a topic of debate for many years, with discussions about the system’s stability and potential future changes. Some retirees never expected that they would face uncertainty about their benefits, especially after the long history of Social Security payments going smoothly.
Political Tension and Policy Changes
The anxiety surrounding Social Security has intensified due to political developments. Under the Trump administration, there has been a push to cut costs and reduce fraud within the Social Security program. However, these efforts have not been without controversy. A recent incident involved Acting Social Security Commissioner Leland Dudek, who threatened to shut down the Social Security Administration temporarily after a federal judge stopped certain data collection efforts. However, after receiving legal guidance, Dudek backed down from this threat.
Meanwhile, President Trump has stated his support for keeping Social Security offices open and ensuring that the right checks are delivered to the right people. But despite these reassurances, retirees remain skeptical about the future of the program, especially as changes are being made to Social Security services. Customer service has taken a hit as the Social Security Administration reduces staff and closes some local offices. Additionally, some services will now require in-person visits, instead of being handled over the phone.
A Delayed Policy Change
In response to concerns, the Social Security Administration announced a delay in implementing a controversial change that would have required people to visit offices in person for certain services. This delay, however, does not solve the long-term issues. Retirees are still worried about potential cuts to their benefits and the impact of these changes on their financial security.
Kathie Sherrill, for example, has already begun cutting back on certain expenses, like dining out and entertainment, to prepare for any future financial uncertainty. With prices rising and the potential for Social Security cuts, Sherrill, like many retirees, is trying to stretch her savings as much as possible.
The Financial Impact of Social Security
For retirees like Sherrill, Social Security makes up a significant portion of their monthly income. Sherrill, for instance, relies on Social Security for about half of her income in retirement. The rest of her financial support comes from her pension and other savings. However, recent market volatility and political uncertainties have made her anxious about the future.
Sherrill’s concerns about her financial future have been amplified by the unpredictable behavior of the stock market. In early 2025, the S&P 500 index suffered a four-week losing streak, which led Sherrill to estimate a $30,000 loss in her retirement investments.
Though Sherrill has enjoyed her retirement with cruises and visits to see her grandchildren, she’s now facing financial challenges. She recently had to replace her car, which was in an accident, and she’s considering purchasing a Cadillac Lyriq, an all-electric SUV. However, if her Social Security payments were to be cut or stopped, she might have to reconsider her purchase. “I may be selling it,” she joked.
The Larger Impact on Seniors
Social Security provides vital benefits to millions of Americans, including about 56 million people who are aged 65 or older. These benefits are used to cover basic expenses like housing, healthcare, and food. For many, the loss of these payments would be devastating. Sherrill and other retirees are worried about the possibility of their benefits being reduced or even eliminated in the future.
Some political proposals have suggested raising the full retirement age, which could further complicate matters for seniors. For example, proposals have suggested increasing the retirement age from 67 to 69 for people born in 1960 or later. While Sherrill never imagined that cuts to Social Security would affect existing retirees, she now fears that her benefits could be reduced at some point in the future.
The Emotional Toll
Beyond the financial strain, there is an emotional toll on retirees who are facing these uncertainties. Sherrill has experienced personal losses, including the death of her husband, Al, a few years ago. His pension and Social Security benefits have been crucial for their financial well-being, but she’s now left wondering how long these supports will last.
For many retirees, Social Security is not just a source of income—it’s a lifeline. Without it, many seniors would struggle to make ends meet.
Conclusion: The Future of Social Security
The future of Social Security remains uncertain, and retirees like Kathie Sherrill are understandably concerned. As the 90th anniversary of Social Security approaches, many are left wondering whether the program will continue to provide the same level of support. While policymakers continue to discuss potential changes, the anxiety among seniors only grows, as they depend on these benefits for their financial security in retirement.
Disclaimer – Our team has carefully fact-checked this article to make sure it’s accurate and free from any misinformation. We’re dedicated to keeping our content honest and reliable for our readers.