A High-Stakes Battle for Water as Texas Faces Growing Demand
In Texas, water is becoming as valuable as oil. A major legal battle is underway over a controversial $1 billion water pipeline project, which aims to transport water from the Simsboro Formation of the Carrizo-Wilcox Aquifer to the rapidly growing city of Georgetown. While Georgetown sees this as a necessary step for its booming population, cities relying on the aquifer, including Bryan, College Station, and Texas A&M University, are fighting to stop the project, claiming it threatens their water supply.
The Pipeline Controversy: Growth vs. Conservation
The Upwell Water project, spearheaded by California-based investors, proposes pumping up to 89 million gallons per day from the aquifer—three times the daily water usage of Bryan. This has sparked concerns that the depletion of groundwater could stifle economic development in the affected areas.
Bryan’s mayor, Bobby Gutierrez, has vowed to fight the project in court, stating:
“We’re going to fight this thing until the end. It effectively drains the water source of the cities.”
On the other hand, David Lynch, a managing partner at Core Capital (which invested in Upwell Water), defends the project, arguing that it follows Texas water laws and that landowners have the right to sell their groundwater.
“We’re following the rules. Why are we being vilified?” Lynch questioned.
This isn’t the first time such a dispute has erupted in Texas. Several similar projects have already been completed, including San Antonio’s 140-mile pipeline from the same aquifer, and others are in the pipeline—literally.
A Broken Water Regulation System?
Texas’ water regulations are fragmented. A network of small groundwater conservation districts governs water use, but many of these agencies lack the authority or resources to regulate massive projects like Upwell Water’s pipeline.
Texas law supports landowners’ rights to extract groundwater, but experts warn that over-extraction could lead to long-term water shortages.
Alan Day, manager of the Brazos Valley Groundwater Conservation District, acknowledges the risks:
“The more pumping from the aquifer, the sooner everyone will reach conditions of scarcity.”
However, he also emphasizes that legally, Bryan and College Station can’t claim exclusive rights to the water.
The Future of Texas’ Water Supply
As Texas’ population continues to explode, demand for water will only increase. Williamson County, home to Georgetown, has seen its population double in 17 years, with projections for further growth due to tech giants like Tesla, Samsung, and Apple setting up operations in the region.
City officials argue that securing water now is essential for sustaining future growth, with plans to supply new residential areas and industrial expansions. However, cities like Bryan fear they could be left dry in the long run.
Texas lawmakers are exploring alternative water sources, such as:
- Desalination of seawater
- Purifying salty groundwater
- Treating wastewater from oilfields
But these solutions are years away from implementation, leaving groundwater pumping as the only immediate solution for expanding cities.
What Happens Next?
The legal battle over the Upwell Water project is set to go to trial in May 2025. If Bryan and College Station succeed in halting the project, it could set a precedent for stricter regulations on groundwater exports in Texas. However, if Upwell Water wins, it may encourage more investors to capitalize on groundwater—intensifying the water wars.
Regardless of the verdict, one thing is clear: Texas is running out of easy water solutions, and conflicts like this will only become more frequent.
Disclaimer – Our team has carefully fact-checked this article to make sure it’s accurate and free from any misinformation. We’re dedicated to keeping our content honest and reliable for our readers.